Personal injury attorneys represent people hurt in car crashes, slip-and-falls, workplace accidents, dog bites, and cases of medical negligence. Their job is to prove someone else was at fault, document the harm done (medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering), and negotiate or litigate a settlement with the insurance company on the other side. In New Britain, that often means dealing with Hartford-area insurers, Connecticut's comparative negligence rules, and local hospital and court systems, so familiarity with those specifics matters as much as general trial experience.
We're tracking 26 personal injury attorneys serving New Britain. When you're comparing them, look past the billboard ads and ask about their actual trial record, not just settlement volume, since a firm that never goes to trial can lose leverage at the negotiating table. Ask who will actually handle your file day to day, how they communicate updates, and whether they front the costs of expert witnesses and medical records during the case.
Our scoring weighs verified client feedback, responsiveness, case outcomes where disclosed, and how consistently a firm shows up across sources, not just star averages. See how we calculate it on the methodology page, and check the ranked guide to the best personal injury attorneys in New Britain for the full breakdown.
Find personal injury attorney in New Britain in your area
No cost, no commitment. Describe your case and we will connect you with qualified attorneys.
We found 26 businesses offering personal injury attorney in New Britain; 25 met the criteria for the scored directory. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is personal injury attorney, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.
Staff including Kinsley, Ebony, and Madeline consistently keep clients informed through every step, explaining the process upfront and handling claims promptly. Clients praise Attorneys Mark Salomone and Morelli for negotiating fair settlements that cover medical bills and more, often resolving cases within months and treating them as family rather than case numbers.
Kevin Ferry and his team earn universal praise for combining sharp legal skills with genuine personal care. Clients describe Kerry and attorney Monique Foley as deeply attentive, responsive to every call or question, and transparent about process and fees throughout long cases. The firm handles auto accidents, workplace injuries, and slip-and-fall claims across Connecticut. Reviewers consistently note that staff members like Melissa and Arlene match the attorneys' professionalism, and that the team stays positive and supportive even when cases stretch over years.
Adam Meltsner and the wider Kocian team earn consistent praise for patient communication, keeping clients updated from start to finish, and addressing questions without making people feel sidelined. They notably follow up after medical appointments and help connect clients to physical therapy, treating cases as personal matters rather than transactions. Workers' compensation and car accident clients specifically report that the firm cuts through insurer resistance and makes the legal process manageable while they focus on recovery. Staff members like Gaby and Lexie are named for extraordinary care and availability.
Clients consistently praise the firm for settling cases quickly and keeping them informed throughout. Staff members like Liz, Elizabeth, Andrew, and Keisha Sandy stand out for treating people like individuals, walking them through paperwork, and making the intake straightforward compared to other lawyers.
Clients consistently praise Robert Weber and Michael Carrier for combining professional legal expertise with genuine empathy; staff take time to explain options and keep clients informed through complex cases. Paralegal Sherri and the broader team earn recognition for patience and support, particularly in long-term injury and accident claims that span multiple years or surgeries.
Find personal injury attorney in New Britain in your area
No cost, no commitment. Describe your case and we will connect you with qualified attorneys.
Carter Mario Injury Lawyers holds a 4.8 rating across 235 reviews, well above the category average. Review evidence is limited to this aggregate data, so specific strengths remain unclear.
Clients praise the firm's knowledge of estate, elder law, and real estate work, with Robert Scalise and paralegal Mary Schmitt named repeatedly for clear guidance and calm professionalism during stressful transactions and family matters. One recent caller experienced broken callback promises over two weeks and abandoned the firm; otherwise, reviews report efficient closings, thorough explanations of legal structures, and staff who go beyond typical expectations.
Long-standing firm with strong client loyalty; Attorney Adrian Baron consistently praised for quick motor vehicle dismissals, attentiveness, and delivering on promises. Clients feel heard rather than rushed, spanning decades of repeat business and family referrals.
Two recent five-star reviews praise the firm as easy to work with and highlight its family-run approach. Review evidence is limited to two substantive accounts, though the 4.9 rating across seven reviews suggests consistent satisfaction.
Clients report strong personal attention and consistent case updates from Brian Mongelluzzo's team, with several praising the firm's warmth and respect during difficult times. One dissenting review alleged mishandling of a workers' comp case, though it remains unsubstantiated against the prevailing 89% five-star pattern.
Reviewers consistently praise Kinga Kostaniak for family law and real estate work, noting her knowledge, empathy, and clear guidance. One dissenting review mentions disappointment with Chris Saracino, limiting overall confidence.
Reviewers consistently praise quick responses and clear guidance through legal processes. Claudia and Pat are named for responsiveness and efficiency; the firm is credited with helping clients move forward on personal matters.
Martin McQuillan and the firm earn trust through attentiveness and genuine care. Limited review evidence, but clients praise responsiveness, professionalism, and fair pricing.
Five-star reviewers call her a trusted guide through divorce, real estate, and personal injury matters. One-star reviews question her credentials in personal injury and express concerns about her ethics and motivations.
Martin Rizzi has earned consistent five-star reviews from clients who value his straightforward competence and long-term reliability. Limited review detail constrains deeper insight into service-specific strengths.
All three five-star reviews praise Attorney Kane's knowledge, honesty, and hands-on involvement. Staff answer phones quickly and thoroughly address client questions; one client returned after 25 years.
One reviewer called John an expert and tenacious advocate worth the trip; another praised fair prices and service. Evidence is thin, but all five-star ratings suggest strong client satisfaction.
A real estate agent with seven years of professional contact praises Attorney Hagel's legal knowledge, accuracy, and ability to deliver correct answers consistently and keep clients satisfied.
Five-star reviews consistently praise Adrian Mark Baron for caring about clients and delivering results. Evidence is limited, but all available feedback highlights his willingness to fight hard in cases.
Limited review evidence: the business holds a 3.0 average across 2 Google reviews with a split rating spread (50% five-star, 50% one/two-star). Their website states over 40 years in practice and service areas across New Britain and Connecticut, but specific details about attorney quality or case outcomes are not evident in available reviews.
Reviewers praise McQuillan Martin for professionalism, kindness, and quick responsiveness. One critic questioned his trial readiness and willingness to take on complex cases.
One reviewer from 2005 praised an attorney for securing SSI benefits; another recent reviewer found the listed phone number non-functional. Evidence is thin: only two reviews, separated by years, with conflicting experiences.
Strong outcomes and deep expertise define reviewers' experience with Mangan. Limited review data, but what exists praises his knowledge, professionalism, and commitment to clients.
Ten reviews average 1.4 stars, with 90% one or two-star ratings. Available complaints include personal harassment, repeated missed appointments without explanation, disorganized office space, and lack of professional communication. No substantive praise for legal services is evident in the review record.
Review evidence is limited. The business claims 15 years of experience and federal court admission across 6 states. Their website lists personal injury and criminal defense among multiple practice areas, though specific client feedback is not available to evaluate performance on those services.
Enquiries submitted through this site's forms may be shared with partner providers who can complete the work, and we may receive a referral fee for doing so. Our rankings and scores follow our published methodology and are never influenced by referral fees.
Last updated 2026-08-15